Some content may contain affiliate links to products which means we could earn a fee on your purchase. Thank you for visiting
If you do not see a peanut butter listed, you can leave a comment and we will get it added pronto!
One of our top picks for Dog Safe Peanut Butter can be SHIPPED to your door. It is the 365 brand that is sold at wholefoods and on amazon. You can click the jar picture and be taken to the actual product to check current pricing.
NO Filler Oils! NO Sugars! NO Salt! Just 100% organic Dry Roasted Peanuts!
How to Use This Dog Peanut Butter Database
Mobile Phone Users, Turn Your Phone Sideways to See All Columns.
To check for Xylitol content, or whether or not a peanut butter is safe to give your dog you can use this list 3 Ways:
1 – Type the 1st Few Letters of Your Peanut Butter into the Search Bar.
2- Sort By Dog Friendliness – Simply Click the Column “Dog Friendliness and all the best peanut butter for dogs will be at the top.
3 – Scroll through the table, all peanut butters are listed alphabetically.
Start Typing Your Peanut Butter
| Brand | Version | Dog Friendliness | Problem Dog Ingredients | Can Cause |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 365 Everyday Value | Organic Creamy No salt or Sugar | Best | None | Happiness! |
| Adams | Creamy Crunchy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Aldi (aka) Peanut Delight | Creamy Crunchy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils Added Soybeans | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| American Garden | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Brad's | Organic Natural | Best | None | Happiness! |
| Brandless | Organic Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Chef's Quality | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Crazy Richards | Creamy Crunchy | Best | None | Happiness! |
| Earth Balance | Natural Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Fisher | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Go Nutts | Most Versions | Deadly | Xylitol | Liver Failure Seizures Death |
| Great Value (Walmart) | Creamy Crunchy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils Added Molasses Added Glycerides | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Jif | Creamy Natural | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils Added Mono and Diglycerides | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Justin's | Classic | Warning | Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity |
| Kirkland | Organic Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Kroger | Regular Creamy Regular Crunchy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Kroger NATURAL | Natural Creamy Natural Crunchy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Laura Scudder | Old Fashioned Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Marantha | Organic | Warning | Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity |
| My Protein | All Natural | Best | None | Happiness! |
| No Cow | Most Versions | Deadly | Xylitol | Liver Failure Seizures Death |
| Nutts N' More | Most Versions | Deadly | Xylitol | Liver Failure Seizures Death |
| Nutty By Nature | Most Versions | Deadly | Xylitol | Liver Failure Seizures Death |
| Once Again Organic | Creamy Crunchy | Best | None | Happiness! |
| P28 | Most Versions | Deadly | Xylitol | Liver Failure Seizures Death |
| Peanut Delight (Aldi) | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils Added Soybeans | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Peter Pan | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Planters | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Prince & Spring | Organic Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Santa Cruz | Organic Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Simple Truth | No-Stir Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Skippy | Natural Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Smart Balance | All Natural Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Smuckers | Natural Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
| Surefine | Creamy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils Added Mono and Diglycerides | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Teddie's | Smooth Unsalted | Best | None | Happiness! |
| Trader Joe's | Creamy Unsalted | Best | None | Happiness! |
| Wegman's | Creamy Crunchy | Warning | Added Sugars Added Oils | Diarrhea Vomiting Obesity Cavities Diabetes |
| Wild Friends | Natural Creamy | Friendly | Salt | Safe Unless Dog Can't Have Salt |
Please SHARE this on Social Media. We are trying to raise awareness for toxic peanut butter for dogs and would like everyone to check their pantry and buy safe peanut butter for their dogs.
For more information on xylitol inside peanut butter, read our other article here: Xylitol Toxicity in Dogs. It has more information plus links to our preferred peanut butter for dogs.
Thanks for visiting SeniorDogDays!